Public VS Private Blockchain: Decoding the Dilemma

Ever considered using crypto for everyday transactions? Maybe for splitting a bill with friends or booking a hotel with your favorite digital currency. Well, blockchain technology is making this a reality – and that's where the question of public VS private blockchain comes in.

Understanding the distinction between these two approaches is crucial. Public blockchains, like the ones powering cryptocurrencies traded on exchanges like Binance, Bybit, or Kraken, prioritize transparency and security. Private blockchains, however, offer greater control and efficiency within a closed network.

So, which path is right for you? Let's dig deeper into the discussion of public VS private blockchain and discover how they can empower your specific needs.

Did you know?

Want to get smarter & wealthier with crypto?

Subscribe - We publish new crypto explainer videos every week!

What Is Chia? | Crypto Finally Explained

SUBSCRIBE

ON YOUTUBE

What Is Blockchain and How Does It Work?

Before we jump into the debate of public VS private blockchain, let's revisit the foundational concept of blockchain technology itself.

Latest Deal Active Right Now:

At its core, blockchain functions as a decentralized digital ledger. Unlike traditional ledgers controlled by a single authority, blockchain distributes information across a vast network of computers. This network constantly and transparently records transactions.

Here's the magic behind it: transactions are bundled together into "blocks". Each block is then cryptographically linked to the one preceding it, forming a chronological chain. This structure makes tampering with data incredibly difficult. Trying to alter a single entry in a chain would disrupt the entire sequence and be instantly red-flagged by the network.

This innovative data storage method offered by blockchain promises unparalleled security and transparency. It's no surprise, then, that it's revolutionizing industries like banking and finance. However, it's not a one-size-fits-all solution.

There are two primary types you should know of: public VS private blockchains. Public blockchains operate as open ecosystems, accessible to anyone. 

In contrast, private blockchains are permissioned networks, where only authorized users can participate. Without further ado, let's go even deeper into these distinctions in the next section.

What Is Public Blockchain?

Unlike private blockchains with restricted access, public blockchains represent the other side of the public VS private blockchain spectrum. They operate more like a bustling marketplace where anyone can freely enter, trade, and witness all the activity happening around them.

In simpler terms, public blockchains are digital ledgers that are completely open and accessible. This makes them a crucial part of the public VS private blockchain discussion.

One of the immediate benefits of this openness is transparency. Every transaction is meticulously recorded and readily available for anyone to see. This level of transparency fosters trust and eliminates the need for a central authority to control the system.

I'll explore more about the advantages later, but for now, remember that public blockchains offer unparalleled transparency compared to traditional systems.

However, there's a trade-off for this openness. Public blockchains often involve transaction fees, a small price to pay for maintaining the network and rewarding those who validate transactions. It's like a library membership fee – you pay a bit to access a vast amount of information and even contribute your knowledge to the network.

Understanding the nuances of public VS private blockchains is crucial for appreciating the full potential of this technology. Let's start by taking a glimpse of public blockchains’ pros and cons.

Pros:

• Improved transparency because anyone can join and participate in the network
• No single entity controls the network 
• A decentralized network makes tampering nearly impossible

Cons:

• Slower transaction processing times
• Higher energy consumption
• Transaction fees can fluctuate depending on network congestion

I’ve established a foundation for your understanding of public blockchains in this section; now let's dip into the world of private blockchains.

What Is Private Blockchain?

Continuing our exploration of public VS private blockchains, we now turn our attention to private blockchains. These types of blockchains offer a more controlled and restricted environment.

Instead of an open-for-all system, participation in private blockchains is limited to authorized individuals or organizations. Because of the controlled environment, it's clear that in this public VS private blockchain comparison, private blockchain fosters a higher degree of privacy and security for sensitive data.

A defining characteristic of private blockchain development is its centralized nature. A single entity or consortium manages the network, making decisions and setting access rules. This centralized control streamlines operations and allows for faster transaction processing compared to public blockchains.

Another key feature of private blockchains is their permissioned structure. Before joining the network, participants must pass a security check by the governing body. This is why private blockchains are also known as permissioned blockchains.

It's kind of like a VIP entrance – only those who meet the criteria get to join the network. This ensures that only authorized users can view transactions and data, fostering a secure environment for sensitive information exchanges.

While private blockchain development offers clear benefits, it's important to consider potential drawbacks. Its centralized control can raise concerns about potential manipulation by the governing entity, as it deviates from the core principle of decentralization that underpins blockchain technology as a whole.

To fully understand the public VS private blockchain debate, let's see the pros and cons of private blockchains.

Pros:

• Faster transaction processing and scalability
• Increased control for authorized participants
• Enhanced data privacy and security

Cons:

• Less transparent due to permissioned access
• Less secure compared to fully decentralized public blockchains

With that in mind, private blockchains can provide greater control but also can introduce risks of potential manipulation and limit their decentralization.

Public VS Private Blockchain Examples

So, now that you've grasped the core differences between public VS private blockchain, are you wondering how these contrasting approaches translate into real-world applications?

Well, buckle up, because we're about to go into some public and private blockchain examples that showcase their power in action.

Public Blockchain Examples

Knowing the core functionalities of public and private blockchains might not be enough to help you choose your perfect blockchain type. To help you see the clearer picture, let's check out into public blockchain examples first.

One of the most well-known public blockchains is Bitcoin, which serves as both a digital currency and the underlying technology that records and verifies transactions. Bitcoin's decentralized nature and robust security have made it a global phenomenon, enabling peer-to-peer financial transactions without intermediaries.

Another prominent example is Ethereum, which functions as both a platform for the Ether cryptocurrency and a decentralized computing platform for various applications. Its smart contract functionality has fueled the growth of decentralized finance (DeFi) apps, non-fungible tokens (NFTs), and other innovative projects.

Solana, another high-performance public blockchain, further expands the possibilities of blockchain technology by focusing on scalability and speed. This makes it a popular choice for projects that require high transaction volumes, such as decentralized exchanges and gaming platforms.

These are just a few illustrations of how public blockchain examples are disrupting traditional systems and paving the way for new possibilities. As this technology continues to evolve, we can expect even more innovative applications to emerge across various industries.

Private Blockchain Examples

While public blockchains offer many advantages, situations often arise where controlled access and heightened privacy are critical. Let's explore how they address these needs through these private blockchain examples.

First, there's Hyperledger Fabric, a popular open-source platform widely used for developing enterprise-grade blockchain solutions. It's employed in various industries, such as supply chain management, where it can track the movement of goods from origin to destination, ensuring transparency.

Quorum, another notable private blockchain, was developed by JPMorgan Chase and offers both high performance and robust privacy features. This makes it suitable for financial institutions and other enterprises handling sensitive data. Quorum can be used to create private and confidential digital assets, enabling secure tokenization and trading.

Finally, Corda is a private blockchain specifically designed for financial institutions. It focuses on interoperability and privacy and is used for trade finance, supply chain finance, and other financial applications. For example, Corda can facilitate secure and efficient trade finance transactions between banks and corporations, reducing paperwork and minimizing fraud risks.

The potential of private blockchain development extends far beyond these examples. As the technology matures and security protocols continue to be refined, we can expect private blockchain development to play an increasingly crucial role in industries that prioritize data security and controlled access.

The Most Liked Findings

Looking for more in-depth information on related topics? We have gathered similar articles for you to spare your time. Take a look!

Cryptocurrencies

What is Hosky Token? Price, Market Trends, and Buying Guide

Cryptocurrencies

How to Create a Meme Coin? A Complete Walkthrough

Cryptocurrencies

How Do AI Trading Bots Work? A Detailed Explanation

Public VS Private Blockchain: Use Cases

We've explored examples of both public and private blockchains to illustrate their distinct characteristics. However, you might still be curious about how they are applied in real life. Let’s see public and private blockchains’ practical applications in this section.

Did you know?

Want to get smarter & wealthier with crypto?

Subscribe - We publish new crypto explainer videos every week!

What is a Crypto Mining Pool? Is it Worth it? (Beginner-Friendly)

SUBSCRIBE

ON YOUTUBE

Public Blockchain Use Cases

Public blockchain transformative potential is being realized across a wide range of industries, fueled by their unique capabilities.

Here's a glimpse into some exciting public blockchain use cases that showcase their real-world impact:

• Financial Services. Public blockchains are revolutionizing financial services by enabling secure, peer-to-peer transactions and fostering the growth of DeFi applications like lending and borrowing without centralized control.
• Transparency and Traceability. Public blockchains excel in situations where transparency and traceability are crucial. Supply chain management can benefit by recording every step of a product's journey on a public ledger, ensuring authenticity and ethical sourcing.
• Record Keeping and Verification. Public blockchains offer a tamper-proof record-keeping system. This can be valuable for things like academic credentials or voting records, where immutability and public verification are essential.

While public blockchains offer immense potential, their open nature may not always be ideal. In contrast, private blockchains provide a more controlled environment, making them well-suited for specific applications. I'll delve into these use cases in the following section.

Private Blockchain Use Cases

While public blockchains offer unparalleled transparency and accessibility, they might not be the perfect fit for every scenario. Well, here's where private blockchain development comes into play.

Let’s now explore how private blockchain addresses these limitations in real-world use cases.

• Data Security and Privacy. Private blockchains are ideal for scenarios where data security and privacy are top priorities. The healthcare industry can leverage private blockchains to create secure networks for sharing patient data among authorized healthcare providers.
• Streamlining Internal Processes. Private blockchains can streamline internal processes within organizations. Businesses can use them to manage internal supply chains or track the movement of assets within a secure, permissioned network.
• Regulatory Compliance. Private blockchains can be used to create secure platforms that meet specific regulatory compliance requirements. This can be beneficial for industries like finance or healthcare, where data privacy regulations are crucial.

As you've seen, private blockchains offer a tailored solution for organizations that prioritize data security and control. Moving forward, we'll compare public and private blockchains to provide a comprehensive understanding of their respective advantages. 

Key Differences Between Private and Public Blockchains

Now that I’ve told you about public and private blockchain examples and use cases, a crucial question might remain: what are the key differences between public VS private blockchains? Let’s check these out.

Accessibility

Remember the marketplace analogy for public blockchains? That's right, public blockchains operate with an open-door policy. Anyone with an internet connection can join the network, participate in transactions, and view the entire transaction history. This permissionless approach fosters transparency and inclusivity, as everyone has an equal opportunity to participate in the network.

Unlike public blockchains where anyone can join, private blockchains operate as exclusive networks. Participation is restricted to authorized users only. This controlled environment is often achieved through a process called whitelisting, where specific individuals or organizations are vetted and granted permission to access the network.

With this permissioned structure, private blockchains give businesses more control over who sees their sensitive data and who can participate in specific transactions on the network. Fewer participants also means private blockchains can validate transactions much faster.

Transparency

Public and private blockchains offer contrasting approaches to transparency.

Public blockchains are like giant online bulletin boards – every transaction is openly broadcasted and permanently recorded on a public ledger. Anyone with an internet connection can see these transactions happening in real time.

This transparency builds trust among participants, as everyone can see what's happening. It also minimizes the risk of fraud since any shady activity would be out in the open for all to see.

On the other hand, private blockchains prioritize confidentiality. Transactions are still recorded on a ledger, but access is restricted only to authorized users. Think of it as a members-only club – only those with permission can enter and view the records.

This approach offers greater security and privacy for sensitive data, making it valuable for businesses dealing with confidential information or intellectual property. However, it also raises concerns about the potential manipulation, as a limited group controls who sees the data.

Immutability

Immutability in blockchain refers to the inherent characteristic of a blockchain ledger where once data is added, it cannot be altered or deleted. This creates a permanent, tamper-proof record of all transactions.

In public blockchains, every transaction is secured using cryptography and validated by a vast network of distributed computers. Once a block containing these transactions is added to the chain, altering it becomes nearly impossible.

Any attempt to tamper with a single block would require modifying all subsequent blocks as well. Due to the decentralized nature of the network, with no single entity controlling the majority of computing power, such an effort would be computationally infeasible.

Unlike public blockchains, private blockchains have a central authority. This means there's a possibility that the ledger could be altered under certain circumstances.

For example, if a critical error is identified, the authority might reverse a transaction. The central authority might have the power to reverse it to fix the error. But here's the good news: these changes wouldn't be done in secret. Any adjustments would be documented and communicated to everyone with access to the network.

Decentralization

Imagine a town without a mayor or central governing body. Instead, residents rely on a well-defined set of rules and procedures to ensure everyone agrees on important matters, like keeping track of community resources. This is the essence of a public blockchain – a decentralized network where no single entity holds complete control.

These blockchains rely on a complex computer program called a consensus mechanism to validate transactions and maintain the integrity of the distributed ledger.

I’ll explain how these mechanisms work in more detail later, but right now, you need to note that the lack of a central point of control makes this type of blockchain more resistant to manipulation or outages.

Meanwhile, private blockchains function more like gated communities. They offer a controlled environment overseen by a central authority, typically the organization that created the blockchain.

This centralized approach brings advantages like faster transaction processing and streamlined governance. However, it comes at the expense of decentralization. Since a single entity controls access and record-keeping, there's a potential risk of manipulation or bias within the network.

Consensus Mechanism

We've established that public blockchains operate in a decentralized manner. But how do they ensure everyone agrees on the validity of transactions without a central authority? This is where consensus mechanisms come in.

In public blockchains, like the one powering Bitcoin, every transaction goes through a rigorous verification process. Every few minutes, a new block containing these transactions is created. Transactions need to be validated by the network itself. One common method for achieving this in public blockchains is called Proof of Work (PoW).

Here's how it works: every transaction is bundled into a "block," and miners compete to solve complex mathematical puzzles to validate these blocks.

The first miner to crack the code earns the right to add the block to the blockchain, receiving a reward in the process. This competition ensures the security of the network since any attempt to tamper with the blockchain would require immense computational power.

Designed for controlled environments within enterprises, private blockchains take a different approach. Remember the concept of permissioned networks with limited access?

These networks rely on a pre-selected group of trusted validators to verify transactions. This allows for faster validation times compared to PoW in public blockchains.

Additionally, permissioned blockchains often utilize alternative consensus mechanisms like Byzantine Fault Tolerance algorithms^[1]. These mechanisms are well-suited for smaller, trusted networks and offer efficient validation while maintaining security.

Efficiency

Public blockchains prioritize security and decentralization. However, this rigorous verification process can lead to limitations in terms of efficiency.

The sheer volume of data involved and the complex computations required for validating transactions can limit the number of transactions a public blockchain can process per second. This can lead to slow transaction times and potentially higher fees during periods of heavy network traffic.

While advancements are being made to improve scalability in public blockchains, they may not be ideal for applications requiring high transaction volume or real-time processing.

However, as of now, private blockchain wins in this aspect. Since they operate in a controlled environment with a limited number of pre-selected validators, the verification process is streamlined. This reduces the computational burden and allows for faster transaction processing compared to public blockchains.

Private blockchains can often achieve faster transaction speeds due to their controlled ecosystem. While both public and private blockchains are exploring more efficient consensus mechanisms beyond PoW, private blockchains generally have greater flexibility in choosing algorithms that prioritize speed and efficiency.

Scalability

Public and private blockchains face different challenges when it comes to handling a growing user base and transaction volume. This brings us to the critical discussion of public VS private blockchain.

Just as I said before, public blockchains are like those bustling marketplaces that are always buzzing with activity. This open environment is great for inclusivity, but it can also lead to some congestion.

During peak hours, when tons of transactions are happening at once, things can slow down a bit. Every participant in the network needs to verify each transaction, and that can create a bottleneck as the network grows. This can lead to transaction delays and even higher fees during periods of heavy use.

Private blockchains are more like express lanes on a highway. Since participation is restricted and the number of validators is limited, transactions zip through the system much faster.

With fewer people involved in the consensus process, there's less congestion, allowing transactions to flow more smoothly. This controlled environment makes private blockchains more scalable – they can handle a growing number of transactions efficiently as the network expands.

Customization

Public blockchain’s core functionalities and underlying protocols are generally pre-defined and difficult to modify. While there might be some ongoing development and upgrades to the core protocol, these changes typically require widespread consensus among users and miners on the network.

On the other side of the coin, private blockchains offer a high degree of customization. Since they operate in a controlled environment with a predefined set of participants, the underlying infrastructure can be tailored to meet the specific requirements of the organization or consortium using it.

Pros

• Very low trading fees
• Exceptional functionality
• Mobile trading app

Main Features

• Very competitive trading fees
• An intuitive mobile app
• Up to 100x leverage available

See All Coupons of Best Wallets

Pros

• A very well-known crypto exchange platform
• More than 500 different cryptos available
• Two-factor authentication

Main Features

• Over 500 different cryptocurrencies available
• Strong security
• Small withdrawal fees

See All Coupons of Best Wallets

Pros

• Fully reserved and transparent
• Multiple tradable asset classes
• Early new token support

Main Features

• 265 supports cryptocurrencies
• Secure & transparent
• Fully reserved

See All Coupons of Best Wallets

Energy Consumption

When it comes to the energy consumption topic, the debate often boils down to public VS private blockchain. Public blockchains can be real energy guzzlers. Remember all that mining we talked about earlier?

It turns out that verifying transactions takes a lot of computing power, and that translates to a hefty energy bill. This is because some popular public blockchains rely on a consensus mechanism like PoW. With this mechanism, miners compete by solving complex math problems to validate transactions.

This process of finding the solution uses a lot of energy because miners need to repeatedly change and find a specific nonce value that matches a target set by the network. This constant competition requires powerful computers running non-stop, which chew through massive amounts of electricity.

As the number of miners and transactions increases, so does the energy consumption. This raises environmental concerns, especially considering that many power grids rely on non-renewable sources of energy, which contribute to a larger carbon footprint.^[2]

While many public blockchains are transitioning to more energy-efficient consensus mechanisms like Proof of Stake (PoS), the overall energy footprint of public blockchains remains a subject of scrutiny.

On the contrary, private blockchains often take a more energy-efficient approach. Since they operate with a limited number of validators, the computational power needed for validation is significantly lower compared to public blockchains. This more streamlined approach makes private blockchains a more environmentally friendly option.

In the ongoing public VS private blockchain debate, it's clear that each type has its unique advantages and drawbacks.

To help you easily compare them, take a look at this public VS private blockchain comparison table.

Table: A comparison of public and private blockchains.

With this public VS private blockchain comparison table in mind, you can now weigh the pros and cons of public and private blockchains to determine the optimal solution for your specific needs.

The Most Trending Findings

Browse our collection of the most thorough Crypto Exchange related articles, guides & tutorials. Always be in the know & make informed decisions!

Cryptocurrencies

How to Buy New Crypto Before Listing and Maximize Your Returns

NFTs

NFT Gaming: How to Buy Gaming NFTs in Order to Play-to-Earn?

Cryptocurrencies

Why Is My Bitcoin Withdrawal Pending? Troubleshooting Guide

Conclusion

So, after reading this public VS private blockchain comparison, which one is right for you?

Public blockchains prioritize openness, transparency, and security through decentralization. This open participation comes at the cost of scalability and transaction speed. As I've mentioned before, popular public blockchain examples are Bitcoin, Ethereum, and Solana that can be traded on exchanges like Binance, Bybit, and Kraken.

Private blockchains, such as Quorum and Corda, excel in controlled environments. With permissioned access and limited validators, they often offer faster transaction processing than public blockchains, but at the cost of transparency and decentralization.

Ultimately, the choice between public VS private blockchains depends on your priorities. Need ultimate transparency and security? Public blockchains might be your pick. Or, are you looking for a faster, greener option with more control? Then, private blockchains could be a good fit.

The content published on this website is not aimed to give any kind of financial, investment, trading, or any other form of advice. BitDegree.org does not endorse or suggest you to buy, sell or hold any kind of cryptocurrency. Before making financial investment decisions, do consult your financial advisor.

Scientific References

1. A. Baliga: ‘Understanding Blockchain Consensus Models’;

2. E. Ghosh, B. Das: ‘A study on the issue of blockchain’s energy consumption’.